GameStop (GME) slid 6% Monday to $25 after CEO Ryan Cohen proposed acquiring eBay (EBAY) for billions in a non-binding cash-and-stock deal.
Cohen’s surprise acquisition proposal would pivot GameStop from a meme stock restructuring play toward e-commerce consolidation, combining eBay’s collectibles and gaming-goods categories with GameStop’s customer base and sourcing expertise, but faces skepticism over dilution and integration complexity.
The analyst who called NVIDIA in 2010 just named his top 10 stocks and eBay wasn't one of them. Get them here FREE.
Shares of GameStop (NYSE:GME) are sliding in early Monday trading, indicated to open down roughly 6% at around $25. The pullback follows Friday's rally, when the stock closed at $26.53, up 6% on the session.
The catalyst is a surprise, non-binding proposal from chief executive officer (CEO) Ryan Cohen for GameStop to acquire eBay (NASDAQ:EBAY) in a cash-and-stock deal worth billions. eBay stock closed Friday at $116.35 as traders positioned around the deal speculation.
Even with Monday's slide, GME stock is up 32% year-to-date (YTD) in 2026 and 17% over the past month.
Per reporting that broke late last week, Cohen has floated a non-binding offer to merge eBay into GameStop in a deal valued in the tens of billions. Reddit's r/stocks lit up with a thread titled "GameStop is preparing offer for eBay, WSJ reports" that drew more than 1,600 upvotes by Friday evening.
The math is what's giving traders pause. eBay carries a market capitalization of roughly $46 billion, while GameStop sits near $12 billion. A second viral Reddit thread, "ELI5: How does GME, with $10B in assets and $4B debt, buy Ebay, a company trading at $50B?", captured the skepticism cleanly.
Cohen built Chewy from scratch into a publicly traded e-commerce powerhouse, and his record on capital allocation at GameStop has been credible. Since taking the helm as CEO, Cohen has overseen the company's debt paydown, retail footprint reduction, and the build-out of a cash war chest from secondary offerings during the meme stock era.
That balance sheet is the deal's foundation. GameStop holds roughly $8.8 billion in cash and marketable securities and has tapped capital markets for $4.2 billion in 0% convertible notes. Strategically, eBay's collectibles, trading-card, and gaming-goods categories overlap directly with GameStop's customer base and sourcing expertise.
Even with that cash pile, eBay's price tag is roughly four times GameStop's entire market cap, so any deal would require massive new GME share issuance, fresh debt, or both. The dilution math is what's pressuring the stock Monday morning, and it helps explain why bullish Reddit sentiment cooled from a score of 80 at midnight to 58 by 6 a.m. ET.
There are operational concerns too. Integrating a global marketplace into a shrinking specialty retailer is complex, eBay's board has not endorsed the proposal, and Cohen's history of social-media-driven communication has previously drawn regulatory attention. Activist eBay holders may also argue the offer undervalues a business that just guided Q1 2026 revenue to $3 billion to $3.05 billion.
This proposal would mark a fundamentally new chapter for GameStop. The 2021 short squeeze gave the company access to capital it never would have raised organically, and Cohen has spent the years since pivoting toward financial restructuring, Bitcoin (CRYPTO:BTC) treasury exposure, and now mergers and acquisitions (M&A) ambition.
The transformation arc is striking. GameStop, a brick-and-mortar video game retailer turned meme stock icon, is now publicly proposing to swallow one of the original e-commerce platforms, an outcome few would've predicted even a year ago.
Investors should keep an eye on GME stock for eBay's formal response, any concrete deal terms or financing structure from GameStop, and signals from antitrust regulators. The meme stock community's reaction on Reddit and X may also drive intraday volatility, particularly if Cohen posts publicly.
Prudent investors may want to size their GameStop share positions modestly until the proposal moves from non-binding to definitive, or until eBay's board declines to engage. Until then, expect both tickers to trade on headlines rather than fundamentals.
This analyst's 2025 picks are up 106% on average. He just named his top 10 stocks to buy in 2026. Get them here FREE.